When Silence Sings by Sarah Loudin Thomas – Book Review, Preview

Posted November 22, 2019 by Phyllis Helton in Book Reviews /

Sign up for e-mail notifications of posts

When Silence Sings by Sarah Loudin Thomas – Book Review, Preview

When Silence Sings

by Sarah Loudin Thomas

Published by Bethany House Publishers
Publication Date November 5, 2019
Genres: Historical Fiction, Christian Fiction, Clean Romance
Setting: West Virginia Great Depression - US - 1929-1939
Written for: Adults
Pages: 384


Colman Harpe works for the C&O in the Appalachian rail town of Thurmond, West Virginia, but he'd rather be a preacher and lead his own congregation. When a member of the rival McLean clan guns down his cousin and the clan matriarch, Serepta McLean, taunts the Harpes by coming to a tent revival in their territory, Colman chooses peace over seeking revenge with the rest of his family.

Colman, known for an unnaturally keen sense of hearing, is shocked when he hears God tell him to preach to the McLeans. A failed attempt to run away leaves Colman sick and suffering in the last place he wanted to be--McLean territory. Nursed by herbalist Ivy Gordon--a woman whose birthmark has made her an outcast--he's hindered in his calling by Serepta's iron grip on the region and his uncle's desire to break that grip. But appearances can be deceiving, and he soon learns that the face of evil doesn't look like he expected.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. This gift did not influence my opinion or review.

Purchase Links

Goodreads Amazon Barnes and Noble Book Depository

Have you ever looked at pictures from the Great Depression era? You know that feeling, that sense of melancholy you get? Almost a stillness, a solemn view of life, and a sense of resignation with just a tinge of hope. Sarah Loudin Thomas takes these same emotions and turns them into prose in a poignant manner in When Silence Sings.

This amazing story pulled me right into the mountains of West Virginia amid a feud that started a century earlier. Where folks lived in conditions we would be appalled at and yet thought nothing of it. Where poverty was so much a part of life it wasn’t even a thing.

The speech of the characters and the narration were rich with the idiosyncrasies and colorful flavor of Appalachian families without feeling overdone.

The conflict between the McLeans and the Harpes was so ingrained into the fabric of the characters, even Colman, who desired to be a preacher and knew the Word of God well, didn’t find it strange or wrong for the feud to exist. He despised and feared the McLeans. In fact, I was set to not like him much when I first observed his thoughts and actions. Then I realized that this was a retelling of the story of Jonah. All of a sudden, my entire perspective changed and I saw how masterfully the author communicated the type of reluctance Jonah would have felt when told to go preach to the sworn enemy of his people!

Perhaps it is my love of stories; nevertheless, I was captivated by the way Colman preached. Not by creating deep treatises on theological teachings but through the simple stories of the Bible, made more relevant and real to his audience. In a community where education was rare, there wasn’t a much better way to reach their hearts!

I was intrigued by the way the issues of prejudice were brought into the story. Not only was there the prejudice of the families towards each other and prejudice against a man of African-American descent, one of the characters lacked pigmentation in her skin and was feared by the people for that.

While there is a hint of romance, this is not a romantic story. It deals with deep heart matters such as hatred, unforgiveness, and pride. And shows the power of God to transform hearts and minds. The ending is satisfying but does not neatly wrap up all the loose ends, much like real life.

This is my first full-length novel by Sarah Loudin Thomas and I hope it is not the last! She is now on the list of authors I really enjoy!

Sarah's When Silence Sings Pinterest Board

(click here to go directly to the board on Pinterest)
  • size: 24x18in Art Print: American Regionalism Poster by Dorothea Lange :
  • Inside a Pioneer Log Cabin | Rustic Cabin Interior
  • Colman Harpe
  • Fashion of the 1930s | LoveToKnow
  • Ivy Gordon
  • blond, albino woman head pose Black and white, grayscale, woman/ female portrait photography and professional headshot from front view, fashion editorial photography made indoor in a studio environment. Upper-body close up photos of beautiful young woman with  wonderful face, eyes and hair in clothes in the best position. Great ideas and inspiration for playing with light and shadow, to create a high key portrait photography.
  • Trio: Lady Edith, Lady Sybil and Lady Mary - Crawley sisters in funeral attire
  • Suit, ca. 1917; MMA C.I.51.97.24a-d
  • Love this for a garden shed
  • Beautiful Vegetable and Herb Filled Basket at the Santa Barbara Farmers' Market from @Karen Wise
  • Basket full of fresh summer herbs. #garden #gardening #herbs #foodphotography
  • basket of herbs
  • sweet peas willow obelisk - So pretty! I like both the obelisk and the sweet peas, I'd like to try this.
  • 25 Stunning Garden Paths - Style Estate -
  • I love the stone boarder. Would love something like this bordering our plant beds in front of the front porch
  • Love the look of galvanized in primitive decor for the cabin.
  • Appalachian Charm
  • Not everyone owned an automobile in the 1930s! In the novel SHADOW OF THE HAWK by K.S. Jones, the Williams family were hard pressed to buy food, let alone gasoline for an automobile they couldn't afford. Excerpt: "Shoot! At least those folks got automobiles, and here we are still with a horse and wagon! We're about as backward and poor as you get, Sooze."
  • Inside a Pioneer Log Cabin | Rustic Cabin Interior

More Shareables


About Sarah Loudin Thomas

Sarah Loudin Thomas grew up on a 100-acre farm in French Creek, WV, the seventh generation to live there. Her Christian fiction is set in West Virginia and celebrates the people, the land, and the heritage of Appalachia. Her first novel, Miracle in a Dry Season, released August 2014 through Bethany House. Book #2, Until the Harvest, released May 2015. Sarah is represented by Wendy Lawton of Books & Such Literary Agency.

A graduate of Coastal Carolina University in Conway, SC, Sarah once dreamed of being a marine scientist. But her love for words won out and she has spent much of her career in public relations and marketing. She currently oversees fundraising and communications for a Christian children’s home in Black Mountain, NC.

Sarah and her husband Jim live in the mountains of Western North Carolina with Thistle–the canine equivalent to a personal trainer pushing them to hike, run, and throw sticks. Sarah is active in her local church and enjoys cooking and–you guessed it–reading.

Tags: , , , ,

To see all current giveaways, go to the Home page and scroll down

For all disclosures and policies visit this link

Purchases via affiliate links help defray the cost of this website. Thank you!

3 responses to “When Silence Sings by Sarah Loudin Thomas – Book Review, Preview

  1. Alicia Haney

    This book sounds very intriguing and like a very good page turner! I love the cover , it is Beautiful! Thank you so much for sharing your book review, I would really love to read this book so I will be adding it to my TBR list.

Leave a Reply